How to audit a supplier: the question list and finding follow-up
In brief
A supplier audit is a process, not a visit: which supplier, which question, which finding, which evidence. The audit principles of ISO 19011, the structure of the question list, finding classes and how the reply returns to the same record.
9 November 2026 · 5 min read
Sample company · demo dataOn-site audits
ISO 9001 requires an organisation to ensure that externally provided processes, products and services conform to its requirements; a supplier audit is the on-site form of that assurance. ISO 19011 is the guideline for planning, conducting and reporting management system audits and lists the principles an audit rests on: integrity, fair presentation, due professional care, confidentiality, independence and an evidence-based approach. These principles are tested harder in a supplier audit than in an internal one, because the person across the table is a business partner, not a colleague.
Which supplier, how often?
Risk: a supplier with a large impact on the product or on safety is audited more often; a packaging supplier and a forged-part supplier do not share the same frequency.
History: recent non-conformities, returns and delivery problems raise the frequency.
Change: if the supplier has changed its site, process or sub-supplier, the audit is brought forward.
New supplier: a pre-approval audit is done before the first order.
The structure of the question list
The question list starts from the result expected of the supplier, not from the clauses of the standard. Each question carries a requirement, an evidence type and a note field. “Do you have a quality system” teaches nothing; “how many non-conformities were opened in the last three months and what were the closing times” does.
Management and organisation: responsibilities, change notification, sub-supplier control.
Process: are instructions in force and on the floor; are critical parameters monitored; are machines and measuring devices maintained and calibrated?
Product: incoming inspection, final inspection, segregation of non-conforming product, traceability.
People: competence records for critical jobs, training, shift handover.
Previous findings: were last audit's findings closed, was their effectiveness verified?
Safety and environment: the minimum conditions the company expects from the supplier.
The audit day
The audit starts with an opening meeting: scope, duration, who will accompany and how findings will be classified. The auditor asks on the floor, not at the desk; sees the document, then watches the job the document describes in place and compares the two. Every finding rests on evidence: document number, batch number, photo, time of observation. In the closing meeting the findings are read together with the supplier; any objection is noted. The auditor does not dictate the solution; the auditor states the finding and the expectation, and the solution belongs to the supplier.
Finding classes
Major: a finding that directly affects the product, safety or legal compliance, or shows that a part of the system does not exist at all. Requires root cause and corrective action.
Minor: a requirement not met in a single instance; requires correction and root cause, with a longer deadline.
Observation: not yet a non-conformity; asked about at the next audit.
Strength: good practice is written down too; the relationship with a supplier is not made of findings alone.
Finding follow-up
The value of an audit shows in its follow-up, not in its report. Every finding is tied to an owner, a due date and an evidence expectation. A supplier reply that arrives by phone or e-mail gets lost; the reply and the evidence must return to the finding's own record. Closure has two steps: the supplier reports the correction and the root cause, the company examines the evidence and verifies effectiveness at the next audit or in subsequent deliveries. An unclosed major finding affects the supplier's approval status, and that consequence should have been stated at the start.
A fictional example
An automotive supplier found that its coating subcontractor was not recording thickness measurements and classed the finding as major. A week later the subcontractor said by phone, “we fixed it”. The company asked for evidence: the last two weeks of measurement records and the calibration certificate of the measuring device. The records came, but the calibration certificate had expired a year earlier; the finding did not close and a second action was opened. The calibration was renewed, the certificate was attached to the same record and the finding closed. No thickness complaint came in the deliveries of the following three months; at the next audit the same question was asked again and this time it was not even written as an observation. A finding closed by phone would have reopened three months later; a finding closed with evidence stayed closed.
Sample company · demo dataAudit programme row
How it is done in Gemy
The audit programme is planned with scope, auditor and date rows; question lists are tied to standard clauses.
Every finding is recorded with its class (major, minor, observation), goes to its owner as an action and closes with evidence. The next audit asks about the effectiveness of previous findings.
A supplier finding is shared with the supplier on the party portal; the supplier's reply and evidence land on the same record. 8D comes as a ready-made record type and supplier findings are answered on the portal.
The external party review stays in the record; if the management of change module is on, an external party review item can land on a change request's impact list.
The product does not score the supplier or make the approval decision; it records the audit, the finding and the reply. Audit and finding records support ISO compliance work.
In short
A supplier audit is planned by risk, done on the floor with a question list that starts from the result, and every finding rests on evidence. Findings are classed as major, minor and observation; good practice is written down too. The value of the audit is in the follow-up: every finding is tied to an owner, a due date and evidence, the supplier's reply returns to the finding's own record and effectiveness is verified at the next audit. The solution belongs to the supplier; the auditor states the finding and the expectation.
You may copy and share this article with attribution (Gemy, https://www.gemydigital.com/en/blog/tedarikci-denetimi-nasil-yapilir-soru-listesi-ve-bulgu-takibi).
Every solved problem is a piece of knowledge; in most companies it leaves with the person who solved it. The four places where knowledge is lost, the view of ISO 30401 and ISO 9001, and five habits that make knowledge independent of people.
Document control ensures the right version of the right document is with the right person. What ISO 9001 asks for, document types and numbering, the approval chain, distribution and reading, withdrawing the old version and the five most common gaps.
A change to a machine, a process or a material should not be applied before its impact is seen. OSHA's five questions, HSE's change procedure, the step-by-step path of a machine change and the temporary change trap.
8 November 2026 · 5 min
Cookies
Essential cookies are needed for the site to work. Analytics cookies load only if you allow them; declining is as easy as accepting. You can change your choice at any time via the footer link.