8D problem solving and CAPA
Finding and verifying the root cause
Listing causes with 5 Whys and a fishbone, then testing the most likely one with data.
- Level:
- Practitioner
- Who it is for:
- Quality engineer
- Duration:
- 1 min
In this lesson
- Build a 5 Whys chain with evidence
- Group causes on a fishbone
- Verify the root cause with data
A frequent mistake in root-cause work is stopping at the first answer that comes to mind. The aim is not to find someone to blame but to see where the process allowed the result.
Build the 5 Whys chain with evidence
Tie the answer to every "why?" to evidence: a measurement, a record or a condition seen on the floor. An answer without evidence is a guess; stop the chain there and collect data.
Widen it with a fishbone
A single chain can miss other possible causes. On a fishbone, gather causes under people, machine, material, method, measurement and environment. Let the team write a few possibilities for each heading.
Verify
After choosing the most likely cause, test it. Does the problem disappear when the cause is removed? Does it come back when the cause returns? If you can say yes to both, you have found the root cause.
- Do not end the chain on an answer without evidence.
- Record the causes you ruled out and why.
- Note who did the verification and when.
Check yourself
There is no score; tap a question to see the answer.
What do you do with a "why" answer that has no evidence?
Stop the chain there and collect data; an answer without evidence is a guess.
What are the two questions that verify a root cause?
Does the problem disappear when the cause is removed, and does it return when the cause comes back?
Sources
- EA23-002 Attachment, Request 16: Global 8D (G8D) disciplines D0–D8 (Ford Motor Company response). Opens in a new tab (PDF), U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) (accessed 15 November 2026)
- 5 Whys, Lean Enterprise Institute (accessed 15 November 2026)