One point lessons and training impact
Seeing training show up in the work
Telling apart the four levels of training, asking the person and the manager separately about the job, and showing the result as before and after.
- Level:
- Practitioner
- Who it is for:
- HR and training lead, Shift supervisor
- Duration:
- 1 min
In this lesson
- Tell apart the four levels of training
- Ask the person and the manager separately about transfer to the job
- Show the result with before and after values
Showing that training took place is easy: an attendance list is enough. Showing that it reached the work needs more evidence.
Four levels
- Reaction: how the participants found the training.
- Learning: how much of it they could show in an exam or a practical task.
- Behaviour: whether they use the new method back on the job.
- Results: whether the targeted count of defects, stops or events changed.
The levels do not stand in for each other. High satisfaction does not show learning, and a passed exam does not show transfer to the job.
Ask about behaviour in two places
Some time after the training, ask the person and their first-line manager separately. The manager sees the work on the floor; the person says what they found hard. If the two answers differ, watch the job on the floor.
Show the result as before and after
Choose the measure the training is meant to change at the start and write its value before the training. After a set time, look at the same measure again. The change may have other causes too; write that down with the result.
Check yourself
There is no score; tap a question to see the answer.
Does passing the exam mean the person does the job right?
No; the exam shows learning, and transfer to the job is asked about or watched separately.
Why ask the person and the manager separately about behaviour?
The manager sees the work on the floor and the person says where they struggle; the two answers complete each other.
When is the result measure chosen?
Before the training; without a before value, the change cannot be shown.
Sources
- Donald L. Kirkpatrick, Evaluating Training Programs: The Four Levels. Berrett-Koehler, 1994.
- What is The Kirkpatrick Model?, Kirkpatrick Partners (accessed 16 November 2026)
- Safety Management: Education and Training, Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) (accessed 15 November 2026)
- What is competence?, Health and Safety Executive (HSE) (accessed 15 November 2026)