Supplier evaluation and second-party audits
Setting supplier criteria and the score
Writing the criteria and their weights, using scores counted from records alongside manual scores, and tying the score to a class.
- Level:
- Practitioner
- Who it is for:
- Quality engineer
- Duration:
- 1 min
In this lesson
- Write the criteria and their weights
- Use manual scores and scores counted from records together
- Tie the total score to a class and a response
An evaluation is reliable to the extent that two people can give the same supplier the same score. The way to get there is to write the criterion, its source and its weight in advance.
Choose the criteria
- Quality: nonconformity and complaint records opened in the period.
- Delivery: shipments that arrived on time and complete.
- Documents: whether certificates and permits are valid.
- Cooperation: whether requested corrective actions are closed on time.
Keep the number of criteria small. Each criterion serves one decision question: how do we go on with this supplier?
Write where the score comes from
Do not score by hand a criterion that can be counted from records; a record count does not change from person to person. Define each step of a manual score, so that what a "4" means is written down.
Class and response
Calculate the total score as a weighted average and split it into classes. Write a response for each class: continue, monitor or a development plan. When the class changes, the response changes too.
Check yourself
There is no score; tap a question to see the answer.
Why not score by hand a criterion that can be counted from records?
A record count does not change from person to person; a manual score depends on the evaluator's judgement.
Why write a response for each class?
A score should lead to a decision; without a response, the score is only a number.
Sources
- ISO 9001:2026 Quality management systems, Requirements, International Organization for Standardization (ISO) (accessed 16 November 2026)
- ISO 9000:2026 Quality management, Fundamentals and vocabulary, International Organization for Standardization (ISO) (accessed 16 November 2026)